After such a long hiatus, i look back at everything here and it strikes me as written by a different person. Perhaps this is a reassuring reaction, since it would be a bad sign, perhaps, if i still felt exactly the same (even though that self-recognition is generally what we seem to be looking for in rereading ourselves).
Anyways, on the occasion of the new year, I'm also starting to have the feeling that things are coming back and knitting together, in ways that demonstrate a certain continuity that I could never see before.
An important example: at the Jandek show, I realized that I hadn't been thinking about improvised music for a long time, and the ways that it provides a model for the genre thinking in film that i've been preoccupied with these last few years (since the last posts here). The show was remarkable in its structuralism. It began with the three performers (Jandek-guitar/voice; Mike Watt-bass; B.J. Miller-drums) on a stark, backlit stage, and the sharp sounds of emphatic drumbeats, commanding attention, calling for response, perhaps, or just marking the boundaries of the performance.
Over these heavy drumbeats, the bass began to add to the architecture of the sound, contributing a rhythmic foundation, like the deep, sturdy layer of muscle over the bones. Then, Jandek's guitar came in with a jangly, dischordant layer hovering over this thick base. I wondered how difficult it might have been not to play in time with the drumming, and somehow refuse the insistence of the beat. More than the sounds of the guitar, at first I mainly noticed Jandek's fluid and painterly strumming, again in such contrast to the staccato blows of the drumsticks. Visually, the 3 musicians sort of matched the sounds they produced, with Miller's large, burly presence and Mike Watt's wide-legged stance. (He limped on and offstage, which surprised me, since he seemed so totally solid, with his long legs unbent, steady as a sawhorse.) Both Watt and Miller wore street clothes, also, as if they were hanging out in the garage. Jandek, on the other hand, was in head-to-toe black, his leather shoes and belt the same satiny black finish, and so thin that he resembled a stick figure. This effect of a willowy, fluid, being with no mass, enhanced the otherworldliness and evanescence of his guitar and voice, making him not only more enigmatic and more ghostly, but also more generic.
Miller's powerful drumming was machinic--both like a drum-machine and like a jackhammer--and as such tremendously physical. I read in Jandek's Wikipedia profile that he once worked as a machinist, and I imagine that he practiced creating his own world in that environment, against the bodily possession of the heavy machinery and its inexorable rhythm.
There were no pauses in the playing, except once, where one of the drums in the drum-kit collapsed on its stand, probably from the repeated force being applied to it. There was a bit of laughter and a moment of relief and applause from the audience, who'd been being encircled by a taut coil of sound since the first, launching drumbeats. In its seeming inexhaustability and the subtlety of its gradations and shifts, the whole set seemed tightly orchestrated, as if everything had been painstakingly timed and planned. The driving beat of the drums provided a smooth structure, like newly laid asphalt, for the guitar and bass to trade places with each other in the foreground and background, and as their volleys also seemed too well synchronized.
Jandek's guitar shifted easily between a diffused, atonality, like a fog, enveloping the other instruments, to a sharp and reedy top-layer of sound, against the meaty backdrop of regularity. Just when the 3 instruments would meld into the equivalent of a deep-focus image, then vocals would act as the punctum, and Jandek's delivery was equal parts the emphatic conviction of a preacher, and the knowing irony of a comic. I didn't think it possible that the lyrics were all improvised until after the show, reading that B.J. Miller had told the OC Weekly that he had no idea what to expect, and that previous live performances were almost completely improvised. This shifted my perception of the show entirely, and made me rethink the nature of the relationship between the musicians, and wonder how Jandek (or the situation) was able to elicit such a tight performance from all involved.
One reason that the lyrics seemed entirely composed was because they were delivered in tempo and with such deliberate phrasing that they sounded necessarily rehearsed. Maybe they were, I don't know. There was, after all, a rehearsal. The other reason was that they were so familiar...so cliche. For a couple of songs, I almost felt embarrassed at how trite they were, and felt they must've been authored ironically, to point to how inadequate/unimportant the words were to the emotions expressed by the music and the interplay between the bodies producing the sounds in the particular onstage configuration. This use of cliches in the improvisational setting makes so much sense now. And perhaps the idea is indeed to highlight the incommensurability of sound and word. Then, on the other hand, there were surprising points of meaning amid the meaninglessness. For instance, the line, "And I was thinking, "why you doing that?" And they didn't answer, because I was just thinking it." or "I relinquished my consciousness//And melded into you//It took forever//And I never did mind." The selfless gesture of never minding when she took forever, is both ironic and literal. Rei mentioned that she kept thinking of object relations, where the boundaries of self and other were posited than blurred then recalled then reconfigured. I think this is also precisely what seemed to be happening onstage, when the instruments would layer, then meld, then separate. In the improvisational mode, the "leader" and the "follower" positions are impossible to determine, since in the delicate play of call/response, action/reaction, the linear relation becomes a circle and then loops back on itself. All this is embedded in the situation itself, and the receptivity/sensitivity that must circulate in order for the performers' responses to contribute to something greater than the sum of its parts.
It struck me that the whole thing was also made possible by Irvine, and the anomalous setting that it provided. We were in Crystal Cove auditorium, but the show still felt somehow like a rock show, even though the physical circumstances were like none I'd experienced before--the frustration of not being able to express my body's registration of the rhythm led to this pressure-cooker build-up of energy, like Freud's clogged hydraulic system. Yet, at times, this shifted to a dullness, especially in intervals of particularly regular drumming, where the wall of noise managed to affect me like a lullaby, despite its actually high volume. Such a controlled yet explosive environment would not have been possible, I don't think, had the show taken place at the Echo or some other venue. It needed to be in the sort of liminal space that wasn't overtaken by the affective distraction of a "scene." The starkness of the stage and the institutional lines and neatness of the auditorium also seemed like necessary elements in the show. There was no encore, and the aural space for reaction from the audience seemed sucked out by the environment. Which I think was to Jandek's liking.
I could keep recounting details--I had the intense sensation throughout the show of both being absorbed in the performance and having an enlarged space for reflecting on what I was witnessing, at the same time; thus, I remember many moments in fine-grained texture. I remember Jandek and Watt slightly turned towards each other, centered on the drumbeat at the base of their pyramid. Both dissolved into the moment, but Watt like a rolling wave and Jandek slightly bending his knees while stretching onto his tippy toes, like the surfer, trying to just skim its surface.
Days later, the performance still remains fresh in my mind. The night of the show, after coming home, I was kind of manic, with an oversupply of energy bouncing around my mind and body. The show was very invigorating, but also maddening, setting off a flurry of of disorganized thoughts, like a startled flock of birds. Mostly, I am left with the thought that the importance of structure to improvisation (the fact that it makes improvisation possible, or the vitality of the anomalous to which improvisational music owes its force and impact) is in some ways very similar to the effect I want to say genre repetition has. But it is just the starting place, the minimum of synchronicity that makes certain relations possible. it's these relations and coincident action, in improvised music, that distinguish creativity from interruption/disruption/disharmony, i think. All the players need to be somehow in relation, even if the sounds they are producing don't come together in what would conventionally be considered a harmonious composition. even this not coming together has to have a relation to a larger aesthetic structure, so that it can produce an effect that does not destroy the relation. thus the lack of synchronicity has to be of a certain kind--one that doesn't break off or destroy the relation. Yet, this maintenance of the relation also has to allow for the unexpected and unanticipated deviation. Or deviation and surprise need to be possible (for the relation to be broken, but only momentarily) for the music to really engage the listener. What exactly is the role or the significance of this vitality of surprise? Is this what prevents mere repetition as repetition compulsion? How does this desire for anomaly fit together or relate to the desire for the lulling rhythm to persist, unabated, like the lullaby, the comforting force of inertia? What is the analogue in the film examples? Is this force, though creative, also potentially disappointing/felt as failure by the audience? When? Why? Under what circumstances? Could this disappointment/failure be a sign or starting point of a relation, or something else?
Showing posts with label Jandek. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jandek. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)