since Wednesday:
Read: Abraham and Torok, The Shell and the Kernel; Bion, Second Thoughts; Melanie Klein, Love, Guilt, and Reparation, selections; Julia Kristeva, "The Priority and Interiority of the Other and the Bond: The Baby is Born with His Objects," from Melanie Klein; and the "Introduction" by John Fletcher to Laplanche's Essays on Otherness.
Watched: Kazuo Hara, Goodbye CP; Bong Joon-ho, The Host (Gwoemul); Yau Ching, Let's Love Hong Kong.
Trying to get to the bottom of the fantasy/drive/wish/impulse (whatever I'm calling it on any given day) to document, record, collect experience, I'm wondering whether it wouldn't be inaccurate to say that documentary is a form of analysis? On the one hand, I'm looking for a link between the psychoanalytic texts/concepts I've been reading and my "non-academic" thought-life (somehow related, I'm sure, to the compulsion I have to forestall the loss of lived experience) and on the other hand, I'm trying to figure out my own relationship to psychoanalysis. With my friend Travis, today, I came to the provisional conclusion that psychoanalysis could be considered a theoretical vocabulary for asking questions that might otherwise be inexpressible. As Freud writes in Beyond the Pleasure Principle,
The indefiniteness of all our discussions on what we describe as metapsychology is of course due to the fact that we know nothing of the nature of the excitatory process that takes place in the elements of the psychical systems, and that we do not feel justified in framing any hypothesis on the subject. We are consequently operating all the time with a large unknown factor, which we are obliged to carry over into every new formula. (my italics)
—-Sigmund Freud, Beyond the Pleasure Principle, 35.
Freud seems to be suggesting, here, that when we want to ask questions about the world but don't have concrete points of reference to use in the asking, we can just substitute metaphors and leave those gaps 'til later. While, on the one hand, this proposition is shockingly enabling, on the other hand, Freud leaves the reader feeling a little had. It's so easy to forget that these metaphors are actually surrogates that we run the risk of finding out later that the foundation for an edifice of thinking/understanding/theorizing is, has always been, nonexistent. Hence, my continuing ambivalence towards Psychoanalysis...
Going back to the question of analysis and documentary, the act of documentation does indeed seem to analyze, if by analysis one simply means to break down, untie, disarticulate. If one thinks of reality in terms of continuity and duration (a la Bergson, for example), documentation introduces cuts into the continuous flow, and enables the measurement of discrete chunks of time/experience. The photograph as document of a single and discrete moment of time is perhaps the clearest example of the disaggregating function attributed to documentary.
In contrast, though, I would argue that the psychic dimensions of documentary--on the part of the documentarist--are mostly synthetic, I think (or non-analytic -- I disclaim responsibility for precise or accurate use of these philosophical terms). Here's where the connection to psychoanalysis lies--psychoanalysis being both a practice of "analyzing" (in the sense of interpretation) the material manifestations of the unconscious, and a practice called upon to safeguard and/or facilitate the integration of the ego. As a means of preventing disintegration, psychoanalysis helps the individual manage to survive the bewildering circumstance of living both as a part of external reality (the body is an object of perception, like all other objects) and as a consciousness, governed by psychic reality. The psyche and the outside world, for the most part, don't have a common reality, though their respective realities might be related. The desire to record elements of the psychic reality that have been symbolized and thus externalized in the form of writing, images, etc., may have to do with a need to project the psychic reality onto external reality in order to control it. Kristeva explains this as "projective identification," a key concept in Melanie Klein's theory of the paranoid-schizoid position. She explains: "Projective identification...is thus manifested as the projection of the parts of the self onto the object in order to possess that very object..." Of course, in the case of the paranoid-schizoid, this identification is problematic ("...projective identification dominates a narcissistic structure because the object is internalized from within and is deprived of its own qualities from without, as identity is assured only at the expense of support from the Other" (italics added)) and the objects in question are the internalized objects--the mother's breast and father's penis--that are split into good and bad in order to manage the ego's ambivalent attitude towards them. The projective identification going on in the documentary impulse is importantly different, I think, though I don't know that I can explain why, exactly. Perhaps because symbolization is taking place in the form of creative production? Sublimation ennobles? In any case, the real question behind these questions: is the documentary impulse pathological?
Sunday, August 19, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment