Sunday, June 22, 2008

give and take

the premise of psychoanalysis, according to sociologist and analyst Ian Craib, is that knowing about the complexities of one's psychic terrain might help keep one from falling apart, bringing one back from the brink, to what Freud calls, "normal human misery." But the whole point of Craib's book, The Importance of Disappointment, which I'm rereading for the third time and which I've been hoarding from the Yonsei library for 4 months, is that psychoanalysis doesn't promise a "cure" from the confusion of being split/ambivalent/at odds with oneself, despite the ways that it's been appropriated and modified to jive with a culture that promises, "the Secret," and gives so much airtime to the message of Oprah's army of fascist positive thinking gurus: perfect self-knowledge/integration manifested in self-righteous consumerism. you go girl! I keep forgetting this and beating myself up for inconsistency, and i've spent a lot of time feeling guilty about neglecting to write, as though the blog could make up for the time spent drifting. (why is it that sometimes, something, esp. the trivial, becomes meaningful only by having been captured--look at this digital photo of lint! instant gravitas--the banality of the everyday, in other words, the importance of the recognition of the banality of the everyday. but lots of people have already noted the power of photos as magic symbol makers).

Here's a passage from Disappointment that's been a particular balm:

"We are integrated and we maintain our integrity when we are aware of our internal conflicts and we can experience them without resorting too much to projection or to any of the other defence mechanisms that psychoanalysis talks about -- denial, rationalisation, splitting, etc. The point is less resolution of conflicts--the existence of conflict, internal and external, marks us off as human--than the way we live with conflicts, the honesty with which we recognise them in and to ourselves. Such integrity also involves recognition that we need our defences, and a complete internal honesty cannot be achieved; and that a complete honest with others is not always desirable..." (38-39).

i realized in reading this that my approach to defensive processes, 'til now, was always tinged with a kind of unconscious moralizing--as if one should stop defending, that the more urgent the defensive gesture, the weaker the ego (stubbornly coded in terms of individual character or merit). So, acknowledging the need for defenses and letting go of the aim of complete honesty with myself is a huge, huge shift.

I get it, now, that not posting was a way of protecting the fantasy that it was possible to express everything I wanted: a) in words; b) transparently, with nothing lost. Fearing the reality of disappointment--that the words always end up sounding wrong and canned and ridiculous--I chose preserving the thinking's intangibility, while also fearing the negation of the thinking, because of its protective-elusive-nonpresence in the world.

we need our defenses--to a point. trying to set this one aside...

My dad told me yesterday that love is not a give and take. If it were, then it would be a transaction, not an emotion. I was struck by how romantic this was, coming from a resolutely unromantic person, as well as how it flew in the face of so much conventional wisdom on contemporary relationships (cf. last week's NYT magazine cover story on equal-parenting). Nonetheless, I found it intuitively wise and moving and helpful.

So, I am trying to figure out, or have been trying (for the past 9 months), why identification is so frightening for me, yet exerts such a powerful hold. And, correspondingly, what a non-identificatory empathy would look like/be like? A non-moralizing ethics? whatever, huh? Another ongoing query: what's a non-pessimistic, non-reactionary negativity? A fear of change and loss that's not retrograde? Mourning without rage? Grief without self-pity? I'm feeling inconsolable about the loss of my cat, who never changed, who'd been my only source of constancy for the past decade of my life. I feel worse about this loss than almost any other death i've registered so far. i'm also grieving the loss of friendships--not so much that they're gone, but that situations and circumstances will never be the same again. i'm mourning time and the truism of the give and take. sometimes things don't work that way.

No comments: